The dispute concerned refund claims filed by an SEZ unit for unutilised Input Tax Credit (ITC) lying in its Electronic Credit Ledger, primarily comprising credit distributed by the Input Service Distributor (ISD) towards common input services. The refund claims were filed under the category "Any Other", relying on judicial precedents recognising the refund entitlement of SEZ units. The refund sanctioning authority rejected the claims on the ground that refund of unutilised ITC is permissible only in the circumstances specified under Section 54(3) of the CGST Act. However, the First Appellate Authority allowed the refund claims, against which the Department preferred appeals before the GST Appellate Tribunal.
The Assessee contended that supplies made to an SEZ unit for authorised operations qualify as zero-rated supplies under Section 16 of the IGST Act. It was submitted that the SEZ unit should be entitled to claim a refund of ITC distributed by the ISD, particularly where the ISD, being the distributor of credit, cannot independently claim the refund. The Assessee also argued that the incidence of tax had been borne by the SEZ unit and relied on judicial precedents holding that an SEZ unit can claim a refund of such accumulated ITC.
The Department contended that Section 54(3) of the CGST Act exhaustively specifies the circumstances in which refund of unutilised ITC can be granted. It was argued that the refund mechanism under the GST law does not permit an SEZ unit, as a recipient of services, to claim a refund of ITC, and that the supplier of services is the appropriate person to claim the refund. The Department also questioned the applicability of the judicial precedents relied upon by the Assessee, particularly since certain decisions had been challenged before the Supreme Court.
The Tribunal examined two principal issues: whether the claim was for refund of unutilised ITC or excess tax paid by the suppliers, and whether an SEZ unit could claim a refund of ITC distributed through the ISD mechanism. On the first issue, it held that the refund claims were in respect of unutilised ITC lying in the Electronic Credit Ledger and comprising credit distributed by the ISD. The Assessee's alternative contention that the claims represented excess tax paid by the suppliers was not accepted, as it was not supported by documentary evidence or the applicable legal provisions.
On the second issue, the Tribunal relied upon the decisions of the Gujarat High Court in the matters of IPCA Laboratories and Britannia Industries, as well as the relevant decisions of the Madras High Court, including Platinum Holdings, Urjita Electronics and McKinsey Global Services. It observed that where the ITC is distributed through an ISD, the supplier is not in a position to independently claim a refund of such credit. Accordingly, the SEZ unit receiving the credit is entitled to claim the refund, and its entitlement cannot be denied merely because it is not the supplier of the goods or services.
The Tribunal further held that the decisions of the High Courts were binding on the authorities and the Tribunal in the absence of any order staying or reversing them. The mere filing of an appeal before the Supreme Court against a High Court judgment does not render the judgment inoperative. It also clarified that CBIC Circulars No. 17/17/2017-GST and 24/24/2017-GST merely prescribed the procedure for manual processing of refund claims and did not restrict the substantive right of an SEZ unit to claim a refund. Accordingly, the Tribunal upheld the orders of the First Appellate Authority and dismissed all eight appeals filed by the Department.
The ruling is significant for SEZ units having accumulated ITC arising from common input services distributed through the ISD mechanism. It recognises that such units can claim a refund of the accumulated credit where the ISD or supplier is unable to claim the same, subject to applicable legal and procedural requirements.
1 Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise, Rajkot vs. M/s. Reliance Industries Ltd. [(GSTAT, Rajkot, Final Order dated 04.11.2026).]
Author: Sneha Nandi
BT Associates
Call: 033 2534-2717 /
033 6451-8729
Mail: enquiry@btassociate.com